South Africa appeals against ISO decision on OOXML
Forum » News / Front page » South Africa appeals against ISO decision on OOXML
Started by: pieterhpieterh
On: 1211542345|%e %b %Y, %H:%M %Z|agohover
Number of posts: 3
rss icon RSS: New posts
Summary:
Steve Pepper reports that the South African national standards body, SABS, has appealed against the result of the OOXML DIS 29500 ballot in ISO.
Unfold All | Fold All | +More options
Fold
South Africa appeals against ISO decision on OOXML
pieterhpieterh 1211542345|%e %b %Y, %H:%M %Z|agohover

Steve Pepper reports that:

"The South African national standards body, SABS, has appealed against the result of the OOXML DIS 29500 ballot in ISO. In a letter sent to the General Secretary of the IEC (co-sponsor with ISO of JTC1), the SABS expresses its “deep concern over the increasing tendency of international organizations to use the JTC 1 process to circumvent the consensus-building process that is the cornerstone to the success and international acceptance of ISO and IEC standards.”

Steve writes, "having resigned as Chairman of the Norwegian committee responsible for considering OOXML for exactly this reason, I congratulate South Africa on its willingness to stand up for the principles on which standardization work should be based."

In perhaps unrelated news, Microsoft announced that it would add ODF support to Office. Good news or bad news for free and open standards? Some have suggested that ODF is not completely safe from patent threats but this will become more clear over time.

Portfolio

Reply  |  Options
Unfold South Africa appeals against ISO decision on OOXML by pieterhpieterh, 1211542345|%e %b %Y, %H:%M %Z|agohover
Fold
Re: South Africa appeals against ISO decision on OOXML
pieterhpieterh 1211542884|%e %b %Y, %H:%M %Z|agohover

Yoon Kit Yong has transcribed the SABS letter.

We believe that there is an important question of principle involved and that the reputation of ISO/IEC is indeed at stake. There has been speculation about the need to revise the directives around fast track processing. While such revision might indeed be necessary, we cannot accept the outcome of a process which the existing directives have not, in our opinion, been applied.

Portfolio

Reply  |  Options
Unfold Re: South Africa appeals against ISO decision on OOXML by pieterhpieterh, 1211542884|%e %b %Y, %H:%M %Z|agohover
Fold
Re: South Africa appeals against ISO decision on OOXML
arebentiarebenti 1211786089|%e %b %Y, %H:%M %Z|agohover

Here Alex Brown acknowledges the need for special rulings:

ITTF are perfectly entitled to make special rulings (as they evidently have done, and not for the first time in this project) on the authority of the Secretaries General of ISO and IEC.

In any case there must be an institution which jumps in when procedures are unclear. However, it should be an institution like a civil court that has no stake in the process.

Reply  |  Options
Unfold Re: South Africa appeals against ISO decision on OOXML by arebentiarebenti, 1211786089|%e %b %Y, %H:%M %Z|agohover
New Post